Don’t Spread Your Merit Budget Like Peanut Butter
It’s tempting to give everyone the same percentage increase. It’s simple, feels fair, and avoids some potentially uncomfortable conversations.
But equal increases don’t necessarily mean equitable increases.
When you spread your merit budget evenly, you miss an important opportunity to recognize and retain the people making your greatest contributions.
Before deciding on increases, consider:
⭐ Performance: Who consistently delivers exceptional results?
⭐ Core Values: Who models the behaviors you want others to emulate?
⭐ Critical Skills: Who brings expertise that’s especially valuable or difficult to replace?
⭐ Pay Equity: How does their compensation compare with the market and their peers?
⭐ Timing: How long has it been since their last increase?
Of course, cost-of-living pressures matter. Everyone feels the impact of rising expenses. But a cost-of-living adjustment and a merit increase serve different purposes. One addresses purchasing power; the other recognizes contribution.
And when budgets are tight, those distinctions become even more important.
Your high performers may notice when their exceptional contributions earn the same increase as someone who’s simply meeting minimum expectations.
Differentiating pay takes more thought, courage and communication. But it’s also one of your opportunities to show your best people just how much you value them.
Don’t just distribute your merit budget. Use it strategically to reinforce your culture and retain the people you can least afford to lose.
Needs Some Support?
If you want some help building a powerful workplace culture, let’s talk. Leveraging my 30 years of HR leadership experience in the NFL, I’ve helped business leaders build positive workplace cultures that achieve results beyond what seems possible.
Book a free strategy call here
Let’s go!
Karen Walters
Founder, Beyond Culture, LLC
